DEPOSITING FOR HOUSING/PROJECT LAND AT THE END OF THE YEAR: IDENTIFYING TRANSFORMED CONTRACTS AND HOW TO PROTECT DEPOSIT MONEY
1. Year-End Market Context
The year-end period is typically the peak season for the real estate market. Many investors and brokerage agencies launch attractive promotional programs and discounts to stimulate demand. However, this is also a time when legal risks for home buyers increase significantly, especially for projects that have not completed legal procedures or are not yet eligible for sale under regulations.
2. Identifying Forms of “Transformed Contracts”
According to the 2023 Law on Real Estate Business and the 2024 Land Law, future-formed real estate projects are only permitted to collect deposits or open for sale when they have fully met legal conditions (Construction permit, foundation acceptance, notice of eligibility to sell future houses issued by competent management agencies, etc.).
To “circumvent the law” and collect money from customers when projects do not meet eligibility conditions, many investors/brokers have used transformed contracts, such as:
-
Reservation contracts / Expression of aspiration forms: Essentially a form of advance deposit but under a different name to evade scrutiny by regulatory authorities.
-
Investment cooperation contracts / Capital contribution contracts: Customers transfer money under the guise of “capital contribution,” but in reality, they do not share profits and are only given priority to purchase apartments or land plots when the project officially opens for sale.
-
Promise-to-buy – promise-to-sell agreements / Agreements to sign future contracts: Commitments to sign a sales contract in the future, shifting all risks entirely to the buyer if the project faces legal hurdles or schedule delays.
3. Risks for Home Buyers
-
Total loss of deposit money or tied-up capital: If the project is suspended, fails to obtain permits, or the investor dissolves or goes bankrupt.
-
Difficulty in filing lawsuits to reclaim money: In case of disputes, transformed contracts often contain clauses unfavorable to the buyer, leading to prolonged litigation and difficulty in asset recovery.
-
Inability to determine handover deadlines: As these are not official Sales Contracts, commitments regarding house handover timelines lack strong legal binding force.
4. Legal Recommendations to Protect Deposit Money for Buyers
Checklist before making a payment:
-
Verify project legal documentation: Request the seller to provide full copies of:
-
Land allocation decision / Investment policy approval.
-
Construction permit (for projects where required).
-
Official notice from the Department of Construction stating that the project is eligible for sale/lease-purchase of future-formed houses.
-
Bank guarantees regarding the investor’s financial obligations.
-
-
Carefully review deposit clauses:
-
The deposit amount must not exceed 5% of the selling price in accordance with Clause 5, Article 23 of the 2023 Law on Real Estate Business (applicable to future-formed houses and construction works).
-
Clearly stipulate penalties if either party breaches the agreement (e.g., if the investor fails to sign the sales contract on time, they must refund the deposit and pay a specified penalty percentage).
-
-
Execute transactions via bank transfer: All deposit payments must be transferred directly into the official bank account of the investor (not into personal accounts of individual brokers) with clear transfer descriptions.
-
Consult lawyers/legal experts: When encountering complex or unfamiliar contract templates, buyers should seek advice from professionals before signing.
Conclusion: Depositing money for real estate purchases at the end of the year requires high vigilance and caution. “Legal safety” must always be the top priority before considering discounts or financial incentives.