REMOVING LEGAL OBSTACLES TO INHERITANCE OF LAND USE RIGHTS WHERE THE LAND USER DIES BEFORE THE LAND USE RIGHTS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED
Many families face legal difficulties when a land user passes away before a Certificate of Land Use Rights and Ownership of Assets Attached to Land (the “Land Use Rights Certificate”) has been issued. In such circumstances, can the heirs proceed with the division of the estate even though the certificate has not yet been issued?
1. The Legal Issue: Inheritance of Land Use Rights Without a Certificate
A common situation in practice arises when a family is in the process of obtaining a Land Use Rights Certificate for the first time, but the person holding the relevant land use rights dies before the application process is completed. The family may then wish to enter into an agreement on the division of the estate but remain uncertain as to whether this is legally permissible, particularly in light of Article 45 of the 2024 Land Law.
2. Guidance from the Ministry of Agriculture and Environment
In its response to a citizen published on its official website, the Ministry of Agriculture and Environment clarified that the fact that a parcel of land has not yet been granted a Land Use Rights Certificate does not, in itself, preclude the inheritance of land use rights.
The legal basis for this position is set out in Article 45 of the 2024 Land Law. Specifically, Point (a), Clause 1 of Article 45 excludes inheritance of land use rights from the general requirement to hold a Land Use Rights Certificate when exercising land users’ rights. In addition, Clause 4 of Article 45 provides that an heir may exercise the relevant rights if either a Land Use Rights Certificate has been issued or the land is eligible for the issuance of such a certificate in accordance with applicable law.
Accordingly, the absence of a Land Use Rights Certificate does not automatically prevent the inheritance of land use rights. The key consideration is whether the land satisfies the statutory conditions for the issuance of the certificate, rather than whether the certificate has already been issued.
3. Key Steps in Resolving the Matter
According to the Ministry’s guidance, the relevant documentation should be reviewed to establish three key matters:
-
The legal basis for the deceased’s land use rights: How the deceased acquired or established the relevant land use rights and what supporting documents are available.
-
The scope of the estate: Which portion of the land use rights constitutes the estate left by the deceased.
-
Eligibility for the issuance of a Land Use Rights Certificate: Whether the parcel of land satisfies the applicable statutory requirements for the issuance of the certificate.
Once these matters have been clarified, the family may proceed with an agreement on the division of the estate in accordance with civil law and the applicable laws on notarisation and certification. In parallel, the relevant land registration and certificate issuance procedures must be carried out in accordance with land law.
These procedures are interconnected and may be coordinated with one another, subject to the circumstances of the case and the requirements of the competent authorities.
4. Which Authorities Have Jurisdiction?
Regarding the issuance of Land Use Rights Certificates, Clause 1 of Article 135 of the 2024 Land Law provides for the issuance of certificates to land users and owners of assets attached to land. Articles 137, 138, 139 and 140 of the Law further prescribe the circumstances and requirements for certificate issuance, including first-time issuance for land currently in use.
Regarding administrative procedures, on 31 January 2026, the Government promulgated Decree No. 49/2026/ND-CP to implement Resolution No. 254/2025/QH15 of the National Assembly, which introduces mechanisms and policies to address difficulties arising from the implementation of the Land Law. Notably, Article 15 of the Decree authorises provincial-level People’s Committees to prescribe land-related administrative procedures, including land registration and the issuance of Land Use Rights Certificates.
5. Practical Recommendations for Heirs
First, review the land documentation with the competent local authority. The heirs should contact the authority responsible for land registration and certificate issuance in the locality where the land is situated to have the relevant documents reviewed, determine whether the land qualifies for certificate issuance, and obtain guidance on the applicable procedures.
Second, seek appropriate notarisation or certification services. Documents relating to inheritance must comply with the applicable provisions of civil law and the laws on notarisation and certification. Notarial practice organisations or competent certification authorities should be consulted regarding the preparation and execution of the relevant inheritance documents.
Third, verify the applicable local regulations. As provincial-level People’s Committees prescribe land-related administrative procedures within their statutory authority, procedural requirements may vary by locality. Reviewing the regulations and guidance applicable to the location of the land is therefore essential.